7 Comments
User's avatar
D.Seiple's avatar

I love this article. You say that the “deep skepticism” that “we” have towards the uses of AI (insofar as it opens the way to hyperreality) is grounded in our “core human preference for reality and resistance to simulation.” I don’t disagree with this at all. It’s worth noting however that your use of “we” seems to skirt a remarkable feature of today’s cultural landscape – i.e., the fact that not everyone shares this skepticism toward full-blown AI. Many do not. And I’m wondering what your thoughts are on that.

Reading between the lines of your piece, perhaps it’s not just the nature of our external world that suffers a precessive degradation. What about us, in other words? And what about those skeptics themselves? Not the ones who simply enjoy philosophical discussion and love a good argument. I mean instead the true believers in all this – the ones who reflect on themselves as creatures of technological postmodernity and find no reality within them or within those they are closest to? Is this a case of a worrisome dehumanization, or is it simply an up-to-date story of what the Buddhist monk discovers?

Tomas Esber's avatar

Interesting. I think we prefer real juice versus artificial juice because we have been told artificial foods are less healthy, therefore we pay a premium on something we perceive as healthier. We value real diamonds versus synthetic ones because we see real diamonds as more rare. I wonder, if real diamonds didn’t ever exist, only a single synthetic-diamond factory churning out a diamond a year, whether we’d greatly value the synthetic diamond. As we do Ferraris, or goods from Prada.

We are skeptical of AI because it is untrustworthy, and sometimes tells us blatant lies which we catch onto. If hallucinations weren’t a feature of AI systems, how averse would we be to the technology?

I like the discussion of simulacra. Consider, however, an artist who was born in a basement and lives there without access to the outside world. They have access only to paintings, books, sculptures. The artist writes a novel. Is the novel any less real, given it was not birthed from real inputs, but simulacra?

My point there is before AI, before the internet, we were already creating a hyperreality via painting, sculpture, books. John Milton purportedly read every book ever published. Were his works, then, responding to simulacra just as much as they were to the real world?

Of course, the issue is the neural networks backing generative AI operate differently than do our human ones. Its intelligence is alien to our intelligence. It is mathematical and probabilistic. Ours is electrical and chemical. How similar, however, is our intelligence to that of a dog? A turtle? A goldfish? Let’s say: not similar. We are far more intelligent and capable than them. To compare someone to a dog (or, more rare, a goldfish) is an insult. We are happy to let pets control our actions, though. We are happy to pivot our lives around them. Could we acclimate ourselves to do the same with AI? The answer is yes.

The cartographer’s map wasn’t laid this decade, or this century, or this millennium. It was laid thousands of years ago, at the birth of civilization. The day we invented concepts such as “good” and “bad”. And “you” and “me”. All of which are simulacra. All of which are maps laid atop universal entropy, which does not think in those terms. Therefore it has been in our nature, since our inception, to make hyperrealities of our existence.

Selim Chtayti's avatar

Thanks for such an insightful piece

J.ai's avatar

I kept getting stuck on a slightly different problem. In my case the AI output doesn’t seem to refer to nothing, I feel it often refers to me, other people, papers, conversations, earlier chats, all mixed together and fed back into later thought. So the problem started feeling less like “there is no territory” and more like “I can no longer reconstruct which territory produced which part of the map.”

That eventually pushed me toward a provenance/authorship question rather than a pure simulacra one: what happens when the representation becomes part of the process that produces the next thought? I ended up writing about that through the metaphor of inherited ideas whose “shoulders” can now move underneath you.

https://jaiisyourman.substack.com/p/the-giants-never-wrote-back?utm_source=share&utm_medium=android&r=1n7i49

Your piece was one of the things that made me realize the distinction.

Gary Knight PhD's avatar

As a math educator and former software developer (search engine tech) I agree with the general tenor of your piece. I was a bit put-off by the use of the adjective precessive, which is wont to lie between regressive and progressive. I can appreciate the motivation, as the AI takeover of the landscape of reason and reasoned arguments is 'progressive' from the perspective of the pinnacle of techne, but regressive in its impact on human originality and creativity, let alone authentic interpersonal communication. Perhaps 'precession' in analogy with the rapid but fitful denouement of a spinning top is an apt word, even if the physicist in me rebels. I'll admit it is a creative repurposing, and that's better than an AI regurgitation ;-}

One 'moral' critique I would offer about the thesis that we've little cause for dismay at the simulacrum of AI if we aren't already incensed at the dissimilitude of so much media and advertising. I believe this position under-appreciates what is really at stake with the particular simulacrum of intelligence itself, which current AI represents. This is such a crisis that, unless there is real and substantive objection - such as that of Roger Penrose - to forming the habit of calling the automaton "intelligent", or that it has ideas, or taking the view (even operationally or provisionally) that AI=I , the rapid dehumanization of all realms of policy will be catastrophic.

By all realms of policy I mean not merely infrastructure governance (as in transportation, energy, communications etc.) but government and legislation, educative policy, policing on 'social credits' and personal ethics formerly reserved to 'conscience' and dialogue - now overrun by the 'ethics' of zero-sum games and of compliance measures. If policies are not strenuously made now to limit the use of AI as a technical tool (eg. app coding etc.) then just one capable 'bad actor' (which could well be a trained AI agent) will be able to bring real democracy to a definitive end.

Arpita's avatar

Very well articulated about something that is happening slowly, but very real regardless. I have always been uncomfortable with AI advancement, and the way even I sometimes use chatbots to vent out, discuss ideas as if talking to a real human who understands me 100%. In reality I feel its rare to find someone who understands you 100% because everyone has their own lens and that is what makes us all inherently human. And AI is trying to remove this area of difference which makes every human unique by providing us with answers that we want to hear. I dont know how far this discomfort is useful or informational, but something to definitely investigate on.

Gustavo Nogueira's avatar

This really resonated with me. I’ve been thinking about something quite similar, but through Heidegger rather than Baudrillard, especially this idea that AI somehow gives us back a kind of averaged version of ourselves.

I actually wrote about it recently, and your piece felt very close to some of the questions I was trying to work through. If anyone here is interested, I’d be curious to hear what you think:

https://gusnogueira.substack.com/p/ai-publicness-and-the-averageness?utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web